EMI Valuation Guide: HMRC Requirements, Process & Costs (2026)
Learn how EMI valuations work, including HMRC requirements, share valuation methods, AMV vs. UMV, costs, and the latest eligibility rules for UK companies.
An Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) valuation determines the market value of company shares used in a UK tax-advantaged employee share option scheme. It helps companies set an appropriate exercise price, understand potential tax implications, and obtain agreement on share values from HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC).
For UK startups and growing businesses, an EMI scheme can be an effective way to attract and retain employees by giving them a stake in the company’s future growth. However, valuing private company shares requires careful consideration of financial performance, ownership structure, share restrictions, and relevant market conditions.
This guide explains how EMI valuations work, the difference between Actual Market Value (AMV) and Unrestricted Market Value (UMV), HMRC requirements, valuation methods, costs, and the updated EMI eligibility rules for 2026.
What Is an EMI Valuation?
An Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) valuation establishes the tax market value of shares that a UK company intends to use for an EMI employee share option scheme.
Companies can request agreement of the proposed share values from HMRC’s Shares and Assets Valuation (SAV) team before granting options. The valuation generally considers two important figures:
- Actual Market Value (AMV): The value of shares after taking relevant restrictions into account.
- Unrestricted Market Value (UMV): The value of shares without taking those restrictions into account.
These values help companies determine an appropriate option exercise price and assess the potential tax treatment of EMI options. While obtaining HMRC agreement is voluntary, it provides greater certainty about the share values used when granting options.
What Is an Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) Scheme?
An Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) scheme is a UK tax-advantaged employee share option arrangement. It allows qualifying companies to grant selected employees the right to purchase company shares at an agreed price in the future.
Instead of receiving shares immediately, employees receive options that let them acquire shares when the relevant exercise conditions are met.
For example, a startup might grant an employee options to purchase 2,000 shares at £2 per share. If the company’s share value increases to £6 per share, the employee may benefit from the difference when exercising the options and subsequently selling the shares, subject to the applicable terms and tax rules.
EMI schemes are particularly useful for growing businesses that want to offer employees a financial incentive linked to the company’s long-term performance. However, both the company and participating employees must meet the applicable eligibility requirements.
EMI Scheme Eligibility Requirements in 2026
From April 6, 2026, the UK government increased several EMI scheme limits, allowing more growing companies to qualify for tax-advantaged employee share options.
The main changes are:
| Eligibility requirement | Before April 6, 2026 | From April 6, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum gross assets | £30 million | £120 million |
| Employee limit (full-time equivalents) | Fewer than 250 | Fewer than 500 |
| Total unexercised EMI options | £3 million | £6 million |
| Individual employee option limit | £250,000 | £250,000 |
| Maximum option exercise period | 10 years | 15 years |
These increased limits apply to most qualifying UK companies. However, companies registered in Northern Ireland that trade in goods or electricity remain subject to the previous thresholds. The extended exercise period may also apply to existing options that meet the relevant conditions.
Companies must also satisfy other EMI requirements, including qualifying trading activities, independence, and employee eligibility.
Benefits of an EMI Scheme for Employees and Employers
EMI schemes can benefit both employees and employers by combining tax advantages with incentives linked to the company’s long-term growth.
Benefits for Employees
- Tax advantages: Qualifying EMI options generally avoid income tax and National Insurance contributions at grant and, where the exercise price is at least the market value at grant, at exercise. Gains on the eventual sale of shares may be subject to Capital Gains Tax.
- Participation in company growth: Employees can benefit from an increase in the company’s share value without purchasing shares when the options are granted.
- Flexible exercise terms: Options can be structured around vesting schedules, performance milestones, or other conditions, subject to EMI requirements.
Benefits for Employers
- Attracting and retaining talent: Share options can help companies compete for employees without relying entirely on higher cash compensation.
- Aligning employee incentives: Equity participation gives employees a financial interest in the company’s long-term performance.
- Potential corporation tax relief: Qualifying companies may be eligible for a corporation tax deduction when employees exercise their EMI options, subject to the applicable conditions.
Why Do Companies Need an EMI Valuation?
A company needs to establish the market value of its shares before granting EMI options because the valuation influences the exercise price and potential tax treatment.
An appropriate EMI valuation is important for several reasons:
Establishing the Exercise Price
A valuation helps the company determine an appropriate price at which employees can purchase shares under the option agreement.
Understanding Tax Implications
The relationship between the exercise price and the shares’ Actual Market Value (AMV) at grant can affect the income tax treatment when employees exercise their options. Setting the exercise price below AMV may result in an income tax liability on the discount, subject to the applicable EMI rules.
Obtaining HMRC Agreement
Companies can request agreement of their proposed share values from HMRC before granting options. This provides greater certainty about the valuation used for the relevant grant, subject to the applicable conditions.
Supporting Employee Compensation Planning
An appropriate valuation helps companies structure equity incentives based on their current financial position and future growth expectations.
AMV vs. UMV in EMI Valuations
An EMI valuation typically considers two share values: Actual Market Value (AMV) and Unrestricted Market Value (UMV). The key difference is how restrictions attached to the shares affect their value.
- Actual Market Value (AMV): The market value of shares after accounting for relevant restrictions, such as limitations on transferring or selling them.
- Unrestricted Market Value (UMV): The market value of the same shares calculated without those restrictions.
Both values are relevant to EMI share options, but they serve different purposes.
| Actual Market Value (AMV) | Unrestricted Market Value (UMV) | |
|---|---|---|
| Share restrictions | Takes relevant restrictions into account | Disregards relevant restrictions |
| Typical value | May be lower due to restrictions | Generally equal to or higher than AMV |
| Main purpose | Helps assess the exercise price and potential income tax treatment | Used for determining the value of options against EMI limits |
Example: How AMV and UMV Affect EMI Options
Suppose a UK startup grants an employee options over 5,000 shares with the following values:
- AMV: £2 per share
- UMV: £3 per share
- Exercise price: £2 per share
The exercise price equals the AMV at grant, which can help the employee qualify for favorable EMI income tax treatment, provided the applicable conditions are met.
However, the UMV of £3 per share is used to calculate the value of the options against the relevant EMI limits. In this example, the total UMV of the shares under option is £15,000.
This distinction is important because the value used to assess EMI scheme limits may differ from the value used to determine the potential income tax treatment of the options.
How Does EMI Valuation Work?
HMRC’s Shares and Assets Valuation (SAV) team allows companies to request agreement on the market value of shares intended for EMI options. Although HMRC agreement is voluntary, obtaining it before granting options can provide greater certainty about the values used.
The EMI valuation process typically involves the following seven steps.

Step 1: Review Company Eligibility
Before obtaining a valuation, the company should establish whether it meets the requirements for an EMI scheme. These requirements cover the company’s activities, size, ownership structure, and the employees receiving the options.
The company should also check both individual and total option limits against the latest HMRC eligibility requirements.
Step 2: Review the Company’s Share Structure
The company’s share structure is an important part of the valuation process.
The valuation should consider:
- The number of issued and outstanding shares.
- The different classes of shares.
- Voting and dividend rights.
- Restrictions attached to the shares.
- Existing share options and other equity arrangements.
- Relevant changes to the company’s capital structure.
These details help establish which shares are being valued and the rights attached to them.
Step 3: Prepare Financial and Company Information
The company should prepare the information required to support the valuation.
Depending on the company’s circumstances, this may include:
- Recent financial statements and management accounts.
- Revenue, profitability, and financial forecasts.
- Details of recent investment rounds or share transactions.
- Capitalization table and ownership information.
- Articles of association and relevant share restrictions.
The information should reflect the company’s circumstances at the relevant valuation date and disclose material developments that could affect the proposed share values.
Step 4: Determine AMV and UMV
The valuation considers both Actual Market Value (AMV) and Unrestricted Market Value (UMV).
These values are determined using appropriate valuation methods, taking into account the company’s financial performance, market evidence, share rights, and relevant restrictions.
The proposed values should be supported by documented assumptions and valuation evidence.
Step 5: Submit the Valuation Request to HMRC
The company or its appointed adviser can request agreement of the proposed share values from HMRC’s Shares and Assets Valuation team using form VAL231.
The submission should include the required company information, proposed AMV and UMV figures, valuation methodology, and supporting documentation.
HMRC may request additional information or clarification before agreeing to the proposed values.
Step 6: Review the HMRC Valuation Agreement
Once HMRC has reviewed the submission, it may agree to the proposed values, request further information, or negotiate different values.
The company should review the agreement carefully, including the relevant share class, agreed values, and validity period.
An HMRC-agreed EMI valuation is generally valid for 90 days, provided there are no material changes that affect the company’s share value.
Step 7: Grant the EMI Options
The company can proceed with granting EMI options under the agreed terms, ideally within the validity period of the HMRC valuation agreement.
The option agreements should clearly specify the number of options, exercise price, vesting conditions, and other relevant provisions.
The company must also complete the applicable HMRC grant notification and annual reporting requirements within the prescribed deadlines.
How Are EMI Shares Valued?
EMI share valuations use established business valuation methods to determine the market value of shares in a private company. The appropriate approach depends on the company’s financial performance, growth stage, available market evidence, and the rights attached to the shares being valued.
Valuation professionals typically consider the following factors:
Recent Funding Rounds and Share Transactions
Recent investment rounds or share sales can provide useful evidence of a company’s market value. However, the price paid by investors may not directly reflect the value of shares offered to employees, particularly when different share classes carry different rights.
Comparable Company Analysis
Valuation professionals may assess comparable public companies or relevant private market transactions to estimate value based on financial metrics such as revenue or earnings. Adjustments may be necessary to account for differences in size, profitability, growth, and risk.
Financial Performance and Forecasts
Historical financial results, current performance, and future projections help establish a company’s underlying value. Depending on the business, valuation methods may include discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis or income-based approaches.
Share Class Rights and Restrictions
Voting rights, dividend preferences, liquidation rights, and transfer restrictions can affect the value of individual shares. These characteristics are particularly important when determining Actual Market Value (AMV) and Unrestricted Market Value (UMV).
Minority Interests and Marketability
Shares granted under EMI schemes often represent minority interests in private companies. Where appropriate, valuations may consider the absence of control and the limited ability to sell shares, while avoiding double-counting adjustments already reflected elsewhere in the valuation.
The final EMI valuation should reflect the company’s circumstances, the specific shares being valued, and supporting market evidence. A well-documented valuation helps companies explain their proposed share values when requesting agreement from HMRC.
How Much Does an EMI Valuation Cost and How Long Does It Take?
The cost and timing of an EMI valuation depend on the company’s circumstances and the scope of work required. A company with a straightforward share structure and readily available financial information may require less preparation than a business with multiple share classes, complex investor rights, or significant recent transactions.
Factors that can affect the cost and timeline include:
- The complexity of the company’s ownership structure.
- The availability and quality of financial information.
- Recent fundraising or share transactions.
- The number of share classes and associated rights.
- Additional information requested by HMRC.
- The professional services required to prepare and support the valuation.
Companies should obtain a quotation based on their specific requirements rather than rely on a standard valuation cost. HMRC does not charge a fee for its share valuation agreement service, although professional valuation advisers may charge for preparing the valuation and supporting documentation.
The overall timeline includes both preparing the valuation and obtaining HMRC agreement, if requested. HMRC processing times can vary, particularly when additional information or clarification is needed.
Companies should therefore begin the valuation process well before their intended option grant date, allowing sufficient time for preparation, HMRC review, and the 90-day validity period of an agreed valuation.
How Long Is an HMRC EMI Valuation Agreement Valid?
According to HMRC’s Shares and Assets Valuation Manual, an agreed EMI valuation is valid for 90 days from the date of the agreement, provided there are no changes in the company’s circumstances that could affect its share value.
Companies should grant their EMI options within this period to rely on the agreed values. If the options are not granted within the 90-day period, companies must submit a fresh valuation request to obtain a new HMRC agreement.
Significant events, such as a new funding round, changes to the company’s share structure, or major financial developments, may also affect whether the agreed valuation remains appropriate.
Companies should review the terms of their HMRC agreement and assess any material changes before granting options.
UK EMI Valuation vs. US 409A Valuation
UK EMI valuations and US 409A valuations both support employee equity compensation, but they serve different tax and regulatory purposes.
Companies operating internationally should understand these differences before establishing employee share option arrangements.
| Area | UK EMI Valuation | US 409A Valuation |
|---|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | United Kingdom | United States |
| Relevant authority | HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) | Internal Revenue Service (IRS) |
| Primary purpose | Establish tax market values for EMI share options | Establish fair market value for private company stock options under Section 409A |
| Valuation terminology | Actual Market Value (AMV) and Unrestricted Market Value (UMV) | Fair Market Value (FMV) |
| Valuation process | Companies can request agreement of share values from HMRC’s SAV team | Companies commonly obtain an independent valuation to support a Section 409A safe harbor |
| Main consideration | Share restrictions, market value, and EMI tax requirements | Fair market value of the underlying stock and Section 409A compliance |
| Review timing | HMRC agreement is generally valid for 90 days | Generally refreshed at least every 12 months or after a material event |
Although both processes involve valuing private company shares, a UK EMI valuation cannot replace a US 409A valuation, and vice versa.
Companies with employees in both jurisdictions should ensure their equity compensation arrangements comply with the relevant local requirements. Learn more about Eqvista’s 409A valuation services.
Frequently Asked Questions About EMI Valuation
Yes. HMRC may disagree with a proposed EMI valuation if the supporting evidence is insufficient or the valuation assumptions are not justified. Its Shares and Assets Valuation (SAV) team may request additional information or negotiate a different share value before reaching an agreement.
No. HMRC agreement on share value does not automatically confirm that the company, employee, or option grant meets all EMI requirements. Companies must separately satisfy the applicable eligibility, grant, notification, and compliance conditions.
Not necessarily. Different share classes may have different voting rights, dividend entitlements, liquidation preferences, and restrictions. Each relevant class should be assessed based on its specific characteristics rather than automatically applying the same share value.
Yes, potentially. A new funding round may provide evidence of a change in the company’s value, particularly if it introduces new share rights or materially changes its financial position. Companies should assess whether the transaction affects their existing HMRC valuation agreement before granting options.
Yes. HMRC valuation agreement is voluntary, and companies can grant EMI options without obtaining prior agreement. However, securing an agreed valuation before granting options provides greater certainty about the share values used for tax purposes.
Companies should retain their valuation reports, supporting financial information, share structure documents, HMRC correspondence, and any valuation agreement. They should also maintain option agreements, grant records, and relevant HMRC notifications to support future compliance reviews or corporate transactions.
No. HMRC does not require every company to obtain an independent professional valuation before granting EMI options. However, companies must be able to support the market values used. An independent valuation can be particularly useful for businesses with complex share structures, recent funding rounds, or limited comparable market data.
How Can Eqvista Help with EMI Valuation?
Preparing an EMI valuation requires more than estimating a company’s overall value. It involves assessing the specific shares being offered to employees, their rights and restrictions, and the financial and market evidence supporting their value.
Eqvista’s in-house valuation team brings expertise in private company valuations, complex equity structures, and share-based compensation. Our valuation professionals assess company financials, capitalization tables, recent transactions, and relevant market data to support well-documented share valuations.
Whether you’re establishing a new EMI scheme or reviewing share values before granting additional options, Eqvista can help you navigate the valuation requirements and prepare supporting documentation.
Contact Eqvista to discuss your HMRC valuation requirements and get expert support with valuing your company’s shares for EMI options.
Need an EMI Valuation for Your Company?
Talk to our valuation team about your company’s share structure and valuation requirements.
